top of page
Order
Butter Me Sweet is no longer taking custom orders for the time being. If you have already placed an order, it will still be fulfilled. Thank you for your understanding.
MENU
CAKES
Below are starting prices for basic cakes and a few of my more popular specialty flavored cakes. Pricing can go up depending on the decoration requested, the timing to complete the design, and/or flavor requests not already listed. Please provide details of your cake including flavors, colors or photos inspiration when you place your order. Note that additional requests can change the base total of your order after it has been placed.
Love vanilla? This is the ultimate vanilla cake. Its 3 layers of cake sandwiched between homemade frosting.
*Pricing starts at $45. Specialty cakes can cost extra depending on decorating, timing, and if you request a flavor not listed below.*
Please specify frosting flavor. 45.00 USD
3 rich layers of moist chocolate cake with a chocolate or vanilla buttercream frosting. *Pricing starts at $45. Specialty cakes can cost extra depending on decorating, timing, and if you request a flavor not listed below.*
Please specify frosting flavor.
45.00 USD
This cake is a giant cinnamon roll topped with a sweet vanilla drizzle.
35.00 USD
Carrot cake with fresh carrots, pecans, cinnamon and brown sugar. Decorated with cream cheese frosting. *Pricing starts at $50. Pricing can go up depending on decoration, timing, and any extra flavors you may want to add.*
Please let me know if you want pecans or not.
50.00 USD
This cake is three layers of lemon sponge with strawberry buttercream and homemade strawberry jam sandwiched between each layer. The outside is also strawberry buttercream with fresh strawberry decorations.
*Please note that pricing can go up based on decoration, timing and any additional flavors you want added to this cake.*50.00 USD
A classic cake! Get a red velvet cake that has 3 layers of chocolatey red sponge sandwiched between a frosting. *Please note that pricing can go up based on decoration, timing and any additional flavors you want added to this cake.*45.00 USD
Please email me at libby@buttermesweet.com to discuss custom cake orders. Please include the cake and frosting flavors you are wanting, cake size, and any decorating requests you have. Feel free to attach photos of inspiration so I can better meet your cake expectations!0.00 USD
This cake is 3 layers of my popular cinnamon rolls stacked on top of each other to make a super cute and unique cake. The base layer is 8 inches round with 7 cinnamon rolls, the second layer is 4 cinnamon rolls and the top layer is one 4 inch round cinnamon roll. Each layer is topped with a white vanilla glaze and they're packed with cinnamon sugar. Perfect for a bridal shower, bachelorette party, small wedding, birthday party, or a baby shower.50.00 USD
3 fresh blueberry cake layers with homemade lemon curd sandwiched between them. The cake is encased in a cream cheese frosting and topped with more fresh blueberries and gold flakes.
*Please note that this cake is not customizable.*50.00 USD
BUNDT CAKES
Rich chocolate bundt cake with a tasty drizzle on top.
30.00 USD
Tasty vanilla bundt cake topped with a tasty drizzle.
30.00 USD
1 dozen mini bundt cakes with a tasty drizzle.25.00 USD
Beautiful from scratch lemon bundt cake with a lemon drizzle!30.00 USD
COOKIES
A dozen homemade chocolate chip shortbread cookies topped with Celtic salt and rolled in coconut sugar to create a caramel outside and a buttery inside!!25.00 USD
2 dozen chocolate chip oatmeal cookies perfect for eating with a glass of milk.20.00 USD
A dozen snickerdoodle cookies made with my Oma's washboard cookie recipe. Each cookie is rolled in a special cinnamon sugar mix!20.00 USD
A dozen from scratch chocolate chip cookies filled with lots of chocolate. Perfect for dunking in a glass of milk!20.00 USD
A dozen giant M&M cookies perfect for dunking in milk!20.00 USD
SPECIALTY SELECTION BAKED GOODS
A dozen chocolate donuts that are the perfect cake alternative. Please specify which icing flavor you want and if you'd like sprinkles. Specify sprinkle colors if you would like a specific color. 25.00 USD
Baked to perfect with no grease, these little cake donuts are full of vanilla flavor and are the perfect sweet snack! Please let me know what flavor icing you'd like and if you want any sprinkles. Please specify the color of the sprinkles, too!25.00 USD
Get a pan of these rich gooey gluten free brownies made with almond flour. These are a huge farmers market hit. Many of my customers can't tell they are made with an alternative flour source.25.00 USD
A dozen chewy yet crispy sweet macarons. Each dozen can be custom colored and filled with frosting and filling of your choice. 33.00 USD
PIES
Gooey, sweet, from scratch pie filled with either blueberries, raspberries, or strawberries. Make it a triple berry pie with all 3 if desired. 30.00 USD
Apple pie filled with a combo of honey crisp and granny smith apples. Goes perfect with a scoop of ice cream!30.00 USD
Peach pie made with local Fredericksburg peaches while crop lasts!!!30.00 USD
A beautiful and delicious homemade pecan pie filled with local Fredericksburg pecans, free range farm fresh eggs, and a crust made entirely from scratch with real butter! 30.00 USD
CUPCAKES
A dozen vanilla cupcakes made from scratch with a homemade vanilla syrup for a sweet vanilla flavor with undertones of caramel. Topped with light and airy buttercream frosting in either vanilla or chocolate.30.00 USD
A dozen rich and moist chocolate cupcakes. These from scratch beauties are topped with either a vanilla or chocolate buttercream. 30.00 USD
All custom cupcakes start at $35 a dozen. Please email me at libby@buttermesweet.com to discuss flavorings, colors, and any decorating ideas you want. Feel free to email photos of inspiration!
Pricing goes up depending on custom requests.
Basic vanilla and chocolate cupcakes with either chocolate or vanilla frosting are $30 a dozen. 35.00 USD